Reel in the Savings: Cheap Fish and Seafood Options for Your Alpha-Gal Diet

A person holds an open can of tuna with the lid partially removed. A wooden cutting board with utensils is in the background.

Are you ready to save money at the grocery store? Here’s how to enjoy cheap fish and seafood without feeling like a bankrupt beachcomber.

The information provided on this site is based on my personal experience living with alpha-gal syndrome. I consistently cite and link to expert sources, but nothing published on this site should be perceived as medical advice.

Alpha-gal sensitivities vary by person. You should understand your dietary restrictions, making any adjustments needed, and directing any questions to your physician.

Do you feel like you’ve eaten enough chicken to sprout feathers? Well, I’ve got some delicious news for you! Today we are taking a dip in the sea of budget-friendly fish and seafood options. Even if you live in the most landlocked state in the nation (like yours truly here in Kansas), there are still plenty of ways to incorporate cheap fish and seafood into your alpha-gal friendly diet. So grab your snorkel and flippers, because I’m about to show you how to reel in some deals without sinking your budget.

A bowl of canned tuna garnished with parsley sits on a wooden table. The text reads, "Reel in Savings – Best Cheap Fish to Eat – Sage AlphaGal.

    

In This Article

Cook with Canned Fish and Seafood

Let’s start with canned fish and seafood. These little tins of protein-packed goodness are lifesavers for alpha gals on a budget.

Boxes of Kirkland Signature Albacore Solid White Tuna in water, each containing 8 cans of 198 grams, displayed on a store shelf. The label highlights 42 grams of protein per serving.
Photo Credit: Sage Scott.

Canned Tuna

If you don’t have canned tuna in your pantry, we need to talk. It’s versatile, budget-friendly, and oh-so-yummy. You can whip up a tuna salad, make spicy tuna rolls, or even get fancy with tuna patties.

These are the most common types of canned tuna you’ll find:

  • Albacore: Light and mild, perfect for just about any dish.
  • Skipjack: Chunk light with a strong fishy flavor.
  • Yellowfin: Pale pink, mild, and slightly sweet.
  • Bigeye: Firm texture, less fishy, great for casseroles.

I recommend thinking about how you’ll use the tuna to help you choose between oil-packed or water-packed. Water-packed is great for recipes where tuna flavor needs to shine, like tuna patties. Oil-packed mixes well with dressings in salads or wraps.

Sage Advice: Because tuna tends to have high levels of mercury, the US Food & Drug Administration recommends limiting your weekly consumption to 12 ounces.

Canned Salmon

Buying canned salmon is much easier on the wallet than buying fresh fillets — especially for people who don’t live near a fresh fish market. Plus, it’s already cooked and chopped, making recipes a breeze. Think salmon patties, spicy mini salmon poppers, or a quick salmon salad. Yum!

Lump Crabmeat

Fresh crab meat vs. canned lump crab meat? The price difference is huge, but the taste? Not so much. Perfect for crab cakes, crab melts, or even crab-stuffed mushrooms.

Crab meat grades can be a bit confusing, so here’s the scoop:

  • Colossal Lump: Big chunks, rich flavor, and firm texture.
  • Lump: Broken jumbo lumps, most common in cans.
  • Backfin: Small broken chunks mixed with white body meat.

Sage Advice: Canned crab meat is higher in sodium, so go easy on the salt in your recipes.

A plastic bag filled with frozen shrimp inside a freezer.
Photo Credit: YayImages.

Buy Fish and Seafood in Bulk

There are many types of fish and seafood you can buy in bulk to save you some serious cash. Here’s how to do it right.

Fresh Fish and Seafood

Do you live near a fresh fish market? Lucky you! Get to know the suppliers and you might score a sweet deal for bulk buys. Remember, only keep out what you’ll cook in a few days and freeze the rest. Frozen seafood can last about six months.

Frozen Fish and Seafood

Big box retailers like Costco and Sam’s Club offer great deals on frozen seafood. And guess what? Freezing doesn’t ruin the flavor. It’s just as delicious as fresh. Keep an eye on sales and stock up when prices drop.

Three shrimp tacos are arranged on a white plate, garnished with cilantro, sour cream, cooked vegetables, and red sauce. The plate is on a wooden cutting board, next to a striped cloth.
Photo Credit: Image by Jonathan Amana via Pixabay.

Cook Once, Eat Twice

Make your seafood stretch further by using leftovers creatively. It requires some meal planning, but it cuts down on food waste. I’ve found that using this method with salmon, shrimp, and crab is easiest.

Salmon Ideas

Wild salmon leftovers can become a salmon salad bowl, a poke bowl, or even a high protein scramble when you add chopped salmon to eggs. It stays fresh in the fridge for up to four days, so get creative!

Shrimp Recipes

Shrimp is super versatile. Grill it for dinner and reuse the leftovers in shrimp tacos or a shrimp salad later in the week. Unbreaded shrimp works best for this. Popcorn shrimp will taste delicious in shrimp tacos, but the recipe choices dwindle when shrimp is breaded.

Crab Ideas

Crab is also easy to repurpose. Extra crab meat can go into crab cakes, crab melts, or even crab chowder. Delicious!

A plate with a portion of white fish topped with capers and herbs, accompanied by green beans and a serving of white rice.
Photo Credit: Image by David B. Townsend via Unsplash.

Make Budget-Friendly Substitutions

Indulge in seafood without the splurge by swapping expensive varieties for a more affordable option. Not only will you save money, but it’s almost impossible to taste the difference!

Cod Instead of Red Snapper

Cod fillets have a taste and texture similar to the more expensive red snapper. This is one of the easiest budget-friendly swaps home cooks can make, “Especially when using this white fish as part of a recipe like seafood stew or a pasta dish,” shares Kelly Stilwell from Food, Fun & Faraway Places. “It really doesn’t make sense to pay top dollar for the expensive varieties.”

Tilapia Instead of Salmon

Tilapia has a mild flavor and pairs well with various herbs and spices. It’s also budget-friendly and less fishy than cod. Try it grilled, pan-fried, or baked.

Salmon Collars Instead of Fillets

Salmon collars are a budget-friendly way to enjoy salmon. They’re the meat behind the gills, including the fatty belly meat. It might be tough to find salmon collars in the grocery store. As Jessica Haggard from Primal Edge Health shares, “Ask your local fisherman or fishmonger for these off-cuts. They are usually tossed aside, but you can get them at a great price if you ask.”

Make It Stretch

Rethink recipes and make the protein a supporting character instead of the star of the show. Pasta, rice, and potatoes cost significantly less than shrimp and crab, so build meals around vegetables and starches first. 

A bowl of orange seafood stew with a garnish of green herbs and white cream, served with a side of white rice in a small bowl on a red table.
Photo Credit: Image by Mauro Segura via Pixabay.

Cook Soups or Stews

A savory seafood soup is the ultimate comfort food. It’s rich and aromatic and surprisingly cheaper than takeout. Frugal cooks, like Sarita Harbour from Recipes From Leftovers, know that the best way to stretch a dollar is to make a hearty soup, “Buy fillets on sale, then choose recipes that can stretch. For example, chowders, soups, stews — and even pasta dishes and casseroles — can feed a crowd with just three to four chopped fish fillets.”

Add to Pasta

Pasta dishes don’t need much seafood to feel fancy. A little shrimp, lobster, or crab can go a long way. Some of the most popular seafood pasta dishes are shrimp scampi and lobster mac and cheese. Some cooks even make spaghetti with clams or risotto with mussels.

A white oval dish contains shrimp placed on a bed of arugula, garnished with red currants and drizzled with a red sauce, accompanied by a pair of silver forks placed beside the dish.
Photo Credit: Where is My Spoon.

Toss into Salads

Sprinkle some seafood on your salads for a touch of luxury without the hefty price tag. Crab, shrimp, or chunks of salmon can turn even the most basic salad into a filling alpha-gal friendly meal.

Related Article: 13 Shrimp Salad Recipes You’ll Love

Make Tacos

Seafood tacos are another budget-friendly delight. Use white rice or cauliflower rice and your favorite beans to bulk up the meal without breaking the bank.

Related Article: 7 Festive Taco Bar Ideas to Spice Up Any Gathering

Enjoy More Fish and Seafood on a Budget

Making home-cooked seafood can become a regular affair instead of a rare treat.  With a bit of planning, smart shopping, and culinary creativity you can indulge in fish and seafood regularly without overspending. So go ahead, cast your net wide and reel in those savings – your taste buds (and wallet) will thank you!

Portions of this article originally appeared on Food Drink Life.

Thank you for sharing!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *